Article

Key Ingredients of Healthy Small Groups

Barnabas Piper

Especially in a church plant, where everything is new and footing in every area of ministry is still being established, each group should share the same stable, reliable set of ingredients. 

There is no formula for healthy and effective small groups, no step-by-step recipe to follow. A collection of people seeking to do something spiritual and relational is simply too complex a situation for that. There are too many relational combinations, too many unique church circumstances, and too many variables to rely on a plug-and-play method for small groups. But that doesn’t mean small groups should be a free-for-all. Especially in a church plant, where everything is new and footing in every area of ministry is still being established, each group should share the same stable, reliable set of ingredients. 

Think of small groups like coffee. Every cup of coffee has the same ingredients: water and ground coffee. But the process of making that coffee can vary wildly. Is it filtered water or hard water? Is it a light roast or a dark roast? Are the beans freshly ground or pre-ground? Is it brewed in a drip coffee maker or an espresso machine? Will you add milk? (And will the milk be frothed?) So a simple set of ingredients can result in a wide array of finished products. So it is with small groups. A simple set of ingredients still allows for unique “flavors” (culture, personality, leadership styles, etc.) 

Here are six basic ingredients every small group should have. Emphasizing these will help any church plant as they get their feet under them and seek to develop a healthy culture and consistent standards in every area of ministry. 

1. Consistency 

Pick a time, pick a place, and show up (especially the leaders). Nothing is easier than giving in to the inertia of skipping a week here and there. It is tempting to try to please everyone by moving locations or changing times. But this creates a moving target for visitors and confusion among group members. When groups meet consistently at a predetermined time and place, group members can prioritize small-group gatherings on their calendars. It is easier to invite new people because there are no moving pieces. The group has a chance to establish rhythms and to grow. 

2. Communication 

Every group should have a committed, prioritized communication channel that is not email (at least for most groups). Email is the most ignored, overlooked, full-of-spam communication channel. If leaders want group members to be aware of any announcements, invitations, or discussion questions, then using WhatsApp, GroupMe, a text thread, or your own church’s app is best.  

Clear communication within a group can serve as an extension of all-church communication, highlighting emphases and events. Effective communication pulls people into the group and church spheres and makes it harder for them to drift away or fall through the cracks.  

3. Bible Basis 

I wrote previously about the benefits of basing small group discussion on the sermon text. While I think that format is the best for groups, what is truly the most important ingredient for any small group is the Bible, plain and simple. If a small group is not intentionally biblical, then it is just a social club, and people can find those anywhere. The Bible needs to be the subject of discussion, the guardrails on application, and the motivation for application. Some groups may lean into textual study, while others focus more on biblical encouragement, but those are flavor profiles from the same ingredient.  

4. Honesty 

Church small groups should be places where people are freer to be honest about the hard or embarrassing things in their lives than anywhere else. They should be contexts of confession and genuineness because the grace of Christ is extended and exemplified. Vulnerability should be honored as courage. What communicates to people that small groups are this kind of safe? It begins with people, especially the leaders, being their real selves–not putting on a front, not trying to be impressive, not hiding their faults and their need for Christ’s help. When group members see leaders relying on Jesus, being honest before Jesus, and being gentle with others who are honest, it sets the whole tone. 

5. Prayer 

A small group without prayer can be many things–a learning environment, a laugh fest, an accountability group–but cannot be genuine Christian fellowship.  

Real honesty resolves itself in prayer–taking needs to God and praising him for his mercies. Real Christian relationship is deepened by prayer, bearing one another’s burdens to our heavenly Father. A group can pray together even when everyone is flummoxed by a hard biblical text, in gratitude for a night of fun, and over the needs of members who are unable to be present. Prayer is the power of a small group.

6. Fun

Can you really be friends with people who you don’t laugh with? Is the fellowship genuine if it doesn’t occasionally devolve into silliness? As consistent as a group should be in gathering around the word, they should be just as consistent in making time for having fun together. What kind of fun? Whatever works for the group: cookouts, games, adventures, outings, whatever. Enjoying each other’s company deepens a group’s time in the word, in honesty, and in prayer. Liking each other makes it easier to love each other. So fun really matters. 

These six ingredients are not magic. They are not a formula that demands a particular order of operations. They simply need to be present for any small group to thrive over time. As a church plant launches groups, emphasizing these six ingredients will provide the best, most reliable flavor.  

Meet the Author

Barnabas Piper

Barnabas Piper serves as one of the pastors at Immanuel Church in Nashville, Tennessee. He is the author of several books including, The Pastor’s Kid: What it’s Like and How to Help and Belong: Loving Your Church by Reflecting Christ to One Another. He is married to Lauren and has three children.

More Resources from Barnabas

Get our best content in your inbox

We send one email per week chock full of articles from a variety of Church Planting voices.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name